Friday, September 27, 2019

Historiography, Day 4 - Class Recap


One of the biographies that was an option to read today in class was about Charles Lindburgh, who flew this plane (now on display at the Smithsonian in Washington, DC) from New York to Paris in 1927.

Hello everyone,

Today, we continued our work with assessing how history is told, by investigating bias and what makes someone a "great" American. Here's what we did today in class:

Learning Targets Addressed: 
Behavior LT 1: I can self direct my learning.
Communication LT 1: I can communicate effectively, both verbally and in writing.
Critical Thinking LT 4: I can evaluate information and explanations within a given context and develop a relevant conclusion.

Soundtrack: "Otherside" by Red Hot Chili Peppers. Selected for today because of our discussion about bias and being "one sided" in interpretations of history. Lyrics here.

AGENDA 9/27/19:
News Brief - Meghana
Finish Textbook Examination
Bias and Biographies
Great Americans

Homework: Read the blog. Finish the textbook examination if you did not in class! The next news brief is assigned to: Chloe.

News Brief: Today's news brief was brought in by Meghana, who selected an article about this story: NYTimes.com - Document: Read the Whistle-Blower Complaint. We discussed this story for a bit and then moved on.

We also checked in about the weekend to see if anyone was up to anything interesting or fun outside of class.

Chloe was selected to do the next news brief.

As part of the news brief, we also watched the one minute BBC World News update. Here's the link to see the latest one minute update, at any time of day (it will probably be different from what we watched in class):

Finish Textbook Examination: This was an activity that we mostly finished last class, and the main goal of today was to analyze how the textbooks have looked at singular events in history, and how that might have changed over time. Here is the assignment that was due today in class (it is graded):


Hopefully this was an interesting activity for you to see! We debriefed this activity in class today and discussed what we saw in terms of how the events were described over the course of time.

If you are at home and wanting to look at the class textbook online, it is available on this website in chapters. If you did not finish this assignment and need to see the old textbooks on the cart, they will be in Ms. Ferris's room, N229, during Period 7 and 8 to access.

Bias and Biographies: Next, we continued to discuss historical perspective, as we defined the term bias. Here's the short PowerPoint that we went through:


Bias is unfairly preferring one person or group over another. This often takes the shape in history of people and events being portrayed in very positive or very negative ways, using language that does not present a "balanced" account of who the person was or what actually happened in the event.

Great Americans: The assignment for today (this is also posted in Google Classroom) was to look at a few short biographies of notable Americans through history and to try and assess any biased words in them, whether or not they achieved the "American Dream," and whether or not this person is a "Great American" - students were able to define this however they wanted. Here are the biographies (try to select a range, not just the first three) and the assignment:



The last part of the assignment asks students to write down someone they consider to be a "Great American" - we will be working with this selection next class, so please make sure it is someone that multiple biographies exist for.

If students finished this in class, I encouraged them to start getting familiar with all of the states in our country, which there will be a test on (probably in a few classes). To help, here's a Sporcle quiz.

Thanks, everyone! See you next week!

Wednesday, September 25, 2019

Historiography, Day 3 - Class Recap


A passport is a book that also has historical facts in it! This is my favorite page from my older passport. Kiribati is a particularly difficult stamp to get!

Dear students,

I hope you enjoyed our work with looking at how the telling of history has changed through textbook examination! Here's what we did today in class:

Learning Targets Addressed: 
Behavior LT 1: I can self direct my learning.
Communication LT 1: I can communicate effectively, both verbally and in writing.
Critical Thinking LT 4: I can evaluate information and explanations within a given context and develop a relevant conclusion.

Soundtrack: "Stairway to Heaven" by Led Zeppelin. Selected for today because of the five year anniversary of the death of my dad, who loved this band. Lyrics here.

AGENDA 9/25/19:
News Brief - Moises
Finish "Lies"
Textbook Examination
Work Time

Homework: Read the blog. Finish the textbook examination if you did not in class! The next news brief is assigned to: Meghana.

News Brief: Today's news brief was brought in by Moises, who selected an article about this story: CBSNews.com - Trump call transcript shows he pressed Ukrainian president to probe Biden — live updates. We discussed this story for a while (there were some good questions about it in class!), before moving on.

We also checked in to see if anyone was up to anything interesting or fun outside of class.

Meghana was selected to do the next news brief.

As part of the news brief, we also watched the one minute BBC World News update. Here's the link to see the latest one minute update, at any time of day (it will probably be different from what we watched in class):

Finish "Lies": Last class, we looked at historical perspective and some of the major "lies" people believe about American history. Today, we finished that look at 7 lies told and tried to understand why that would happen, before using that information to move on to a new assignment.

Textbook Examination: The main goal of today was to analyze how the textbooks have looked at singular events in history, and how that might have changed over time. Here is the assignment that will be due at the start of next class (it is graded - paper copies were available in class or it is also available to submit electronically on Google Classroom):


Hopefully this was an interesting activity for you to see! We also talked in class about the importance of citations when you are researching. I gave an example citation for the textbook as:

Author. Title of Book. City of Publication: Publisher, Year. Format.

For the main class textbook, this would be:

Danzer, et. al. The Americans. McDougal Littell, 2005. Print.

If you are at home and wanting to look at the textbook online, it is available on this website in chapters.

Work Time: The rest of class was devoted to in class work time, looking at one of your 5 major events and seeing how textbooks have addressed it throughout time. This assignment was due at the end of class and will be graded for the Critical Thinking LT 4. Thanks, everyone! See you next class!

Monday, September 23, 2019

Historiography, Day 2 - Class Recap


One of the "lies" that James Loewen discusses in his book "Lies My Teacher Told Me" is about Abraham Lincoln being portrayed as single minded in terms of saving the Union, instead of a deep thinker who wrestled with the idea of slavery and the treatment of people of color.

Hello everyone,

Another interesting class today on understanding history! Here's what we did today in class:

Learning Targets Addressed: 
Behavior LT 3: I can communicate and work effectively within a team or group.
Communication LT 1: I can communicate effectively, both verbally and in writing.

Soundtrack: "Love the Way You Lie (Clean)" by Eminem and Rihanna. Selected for today because of the connection to "Lies My Teacher Told Me."

AGENDA 9/23/19:
News Brief - Lucy
Important Events
History
The Biggest Lie

Homework: Read the blog. The next news brief is assigned to: Moises.

News Brief: Today's news brief was brought in by Lucy, who selected an article about this story: NBCNews.com - Tropical storms Karen and Jerry approaching Puerto Rico, Bermuda. We discussed this story for a bit and then moved on.

We also checked in about the weekend to see if anyone was up to anything interesting or fun outside of class.

Moises was selected to do the next news brief.

As part of the news brief, we also watched the one minute BBC World News update. Here's the link to see the latest one minute update, at any time of day (it will probably be different from what we watched in class):


Important Events: Last class, we devoted the end of class for each student to try and identify what they felt the 5 most important events in United States history are. We came back to discussing these events in class today. Next class, we will look a little at what the text book has to say about these events, as we continue to have a critical eye on history.

History: We discussed a question about who or what bears responsibility for the event described, using this excerpt from a book called "What Is History:"


Here's a real life example, regarding an autonomous driving car:


We had another conversation in class about who was to blame for this incident - again, using our interpretations of the facts, as historians do.

The Biggest Lie: Simply put, this is one of the most important books for social studies/history teachers: 


The book came out in 1995, but was recently revised and republished. In class, we read this interview with the author, James Loewen, about the biggest lie that is told in history classes:


As we read, the lie is that America is constantly getting better, all the time, and that there are not times when it is getting worse. We broke up into 7 smaller groups and read through the interview, then I asked the groups to do a little research on the "lies" from the book, which included:

1) Christopher Columbus
2) Woodrow Wilson
3) The first Thanksgiving
4) Betsy Ross
5) Helen Keller
6) John Brown
7) Abraham Lincoln

As a class, we wrote out what we found as the lies about these people/events and had a good discussion about why they are lied about (up to the John Brown group). For more on Thanksgiving, see here: NYTimes.com - Everything You Learned About Thanksgiving Is Wrong. We will come back to this next class! See you then!